Student Loan Borrower Assisstance
  • For Borrowers
    • Basics of Student Loans
      • Student Loans 101
      • Understanding Your Student Loan Situation
      • Federal Loans vs. Private Loans
    • Dealing with Student Loan Debt
      • Repaying Your Loans
      • Pausing Student Loan Payments
      • Default & Debt Collection
      • Loan Cancellation, Forgiveness & Bankruptcy
      • Private Student Loans & Other Education Debt
    • Find Help
      • Help with Your Student Loans
      • File Complaints
      • Help Videos
      • Surviving Debt
      • Share Your Story
  • For Advocates
    • Tools & Resources to Use with Borrowers
      • Advocate Tools & Resources
      • Student Loan Law
      • Borrower Rights After the Supreme Court Ruling
      • NCLC Digital Library
    • Help with Cases
      • Case Consultation
      • Student Loan Law Listservs
      • Legal Aid Coalition
    • Trainings & Upcoming Events
      • Webinars
  • Updates & News
    • Student Loan Borrower News
    • Featured Reports, Issue Briefs, Resources
    • Subscribe
  • Our Work
    • NCLC’s Student Loan Borrower Assistance Project
    • Contact Us
    • NCLC.org

Follow-up to Mr. A’s Story

April 23, 2012

Thanks to all of you who have responded to the story about my client Mr. A.  Many of you have asked why Mr. A has not tried rehabilitation or consolidation to get out of default.  We have discussed these options with Mr. A many times.  They are useful for many borrowers, but there are drawbacks.  Most important in Mr. A’s case, he does not believe he owes the loans and does not want to take any action that would appear to revive the debts.   Further, consolidation creates a new loan and borrowers generally lose rights and defenses, such as forgery, related to the underlying loans.  This information sheet reviews the pros and cons of rehabilitation and consolidation.

Mr. A could consider applying for a disability discharge, but he believes, whether realistically or not, that he should still be able to work.  In any case, this is hardly a straightforward process in our experience and the government denies many meritorious claims.  Mr. A might be able to meet the heightened bankruptcy student loan discharge standard.  Discharging a student loan in bankruptcy, however, is difficult both procedurally and substantively.  Mr. A is not prepared to go to court and present the detailed evidence of his medical condition and other personal testimony required to prove the common sense argument that he simply cannot repay these loans.

We will keep working with Mr. A, but these are the main reasons he remains in default.   However, we encourage you to review these various options as they do work for many borrowers.  The available options are far from perfect.  For example, loan cancellation or discharge applies only in limited cases.  But getting out of default if possible, even though the debt survives, is generally preferable to facing a life time of collection.

We also appreciate the comments about V.A. services.  Mr. A does get some very limited prescription drug benefits and other medical assistance from V.A., but not enough to pay for all of his health care needs.

 

    Recent Posts

    Screenshot Your IDR Progress Today
    Apr 25, 2025
    Collection of Defaulted Student Loans to Begin Soon: What Borrowers Need to Know Now
    Apr 24, 2025
    IDR Application is Back Up
    Mar 28, 2025
    National Consumer Law Center
    facebook
    linkedin
    twitter
    rss

    Student Loan Borrower Assistance is a project of the National Consumer Law Center.

    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Donate
    • Privacy Policy

    © 2025, National Consumer Law Center, Inc., All rights reserved.

    NCLC and National Consumer Law Center are registered trademarks of National Consumer Law Center, Inc.

    Sign up for our newsletter

    Subscribe